GangstaKage vs Nyanki vs Kuro Nagashi

[Silver Cross]

Here is another battle from the Pink land of the RPG. This is the battle between the RPG mods of the wonderful place of whatever you want it to be. Though, due to my promotion being so recent I will be sitting this battle out. Instead I will be running this show.

Theme: Best Role-player Pinky

Badge: Pinky-themed custom badge (still under construction)

Duration: Till next Sunday

Which of these three is the best role-player?

Is it GangstaKage(Ryan), the last remaining original Pinky? With his characters that can easily put the silly mood into any situation his characters enter? Along with his ability to describe the little things in such a large perspective at times.

Perhaps it's Stacy(Nyanki), who's diamond standard role-playing abilities have really raised the bar in our little section? With great characters, each created in such depth you feel as though you know the character on a personal level.

Or is it Kuro, who's mass of character's and ability to rapid post seems to keep an everlasting flow in the section. Getting only better through time, Kuro's detailed and descriptive posts are moving to the top tier of role-playing. He is an amazing role-player, and will only get more-so.

Maybe even Ryan? His amazingly detailed, and often extremely silly posts have been all over the rpg section since its dawn. He is an extremely excellent role-player, and knows what he's doing when it comes to making a Grade A post.

Which one of these excellent people will you choose? T

Feel free to make use of all posts from the Naruto, Bleach, and Other sections as evidence....NOW VOTE!

Notes:
1. One liner votes, with no ground-work and absurd reasoning like "Because I agree with him always" or "He's just better" or something else similar shall not be counted. This decision of counting shall be the discretion of the battle officiator, i.e. the thread creator.
2. Discussion about the participants is allowed in the thread, however, it should not amount to spam or pointless bickering.

Stacy: 4
Kuro: 1
Ryan: 1

[SanoVivente]

Well, a pinky battle royale eh?
This is a hard one, ive seen all 3 rp and payed attention to their posts.
Ive battled Kuro, so i know him the best and i have to say he might be my pick.
Ive also seen how Staceh Rp's and when i look at a thread like Sunagakure or Kankyou town in which Kuro and Staceh are Rping back and forth to each other, Stacehs is BIT more detailed, and well..overall Cooler.
Though ive seen how Ryan RP's as well, and honestly hes Even with Stacy, hes got a bit of funny in his posts more than stacy does, and im a comedy man.
So this is a tough one, but Im gonna have to pick STACEH.
Theres to many posts ive observed to pick a certain one that makes the most evidence..or something along these lines.
So yeah, stacy is my pick.

[Anthony Sky]

A battle of the Pinkies , the role models for all RPGer's. With that said this is a hard one. I cant say I pay attention to the mods in character posts more then others , but I can say I pay attentions to everyone's in character posts. So it is fair to say I have seen each one RP and on top of that have RP with each one pretty extensively.

Stacy has nice a fluid rhythm to her post , with both a fair amount of detail and inquisitiveness , what I mean by saying inquisitiveness is the fact she shows her character thoughts about thing and has them ask them selves questions , like she is leading the other RPer into what would be good talking point , this is very helpful for new characters and getting them active. Her characters are nice but sometimes they leave me wanting more , like there appearance or even history. But the thing that makes up for that is the fact each one has theme or inspiration what makes the character feel like a whole.

Kuro: Kuro has most defiantly grown in his RPing skills more then anyone else I have seen , in the RPG section. He went from one paragraph to three , bravo Kuro , with that came more detail what is always a joy when RPing. His mass of characters always have a mission and purpose , what makes it fun to interact with them. But I do feel kuro still has some growing to do or in better words more potential.

Ryan: There is now doubt that his post are in the very top of the best of the best , each one with amazing detail that I my self would never think of including. Then there is his characters , amazing characters , I always find myself going over them when I am bored because they are so creative and full of depth , I always find new stuff to think of them. But he does take awhile to post sometimes , what is his weakest flaw.

Then there is his ability to make some breath taking post , that from the beginning to end make you want to read on and on , the moods are always so perfect never seeming out of place. and because of this ability I give my vote to Ryan.

But I would like to say this to close my post , just like Hitsugaya being prodigy and always getting stronger , Kuro is always getting better with his post and perhaps in a year or so he will be better then Ryan , just as Hitsugaya will be perhaps stronger then Shunsui in 100 years.

[Silver Cross]

So that's one for Stacy and one for Ryan! Keep them comin' people!

[Kuro Nagashi]

First thing is first, Stacy dominates all areas of RPing, starting with comedy first.

http://www.talknaruto.com/showpost.p...7&postcount=61

http://www.talknaruto.com/showpost.p...&postcount=376

Then there is the romantic area, I don't need to provide links for that. Those that have seen her RP with Shigeko in certain threads will agree with me on this. So she has that going for her as well. I mean she can just take the breath right out of a person without even trying.

Along with that, she is getting better at fighting, she may not be the best. Though she is on her way to being a super awesome pwning fighter.

Not to mention the thought and depth behind her characters, like each one is a part of her. Reading them makes you want to read more even though she has overflowed you with information and emotions in her characters. So my vote goes to Stacy.

---

OKAY GUYS, COME ON!!!! VOTE VOTE VOTE!!!

[taiyana_chan]

ooh....this is tough.!
you guys are RPG mods for a reason.!

my vote goes to Stacy. she's amazingly detailed in each of her posts and I can perfectly visualize the events taking place. She actually takes the time to think of what she's going to say and I believe that she's very fair whenever she has to make a Pinky decision lol. Kuro and Ryan are both amazing too though.

[Jackums]

I'm giving my vote to Stacy.

Her posts are sometimes a little short, but they're always top quality. She doesn't constantly use cliche words/terms and she keeps her posts detailed. Her characters are fairly unique and they don't rely on raw power. She also knows the limits she can go to, not overpowering her characters. An all-around good role-player.

Overall, the best of the three, although they all have strong points.

[GangstaKage]

Okay, Lets start of with...I hope my most is allowed because otherwise I'm flipping a coin xD This took a while of thinking and I'm being as unbiased as possible:

Okay let's start with Stacy, ahhh Stacy. What makes her characters so loveable is not the creativeness, and not even the simplicity yet detail in them. It's her willingness of making a nice char. to just hang out and to rank up. She proves that just taking time to work with your characters isamazing and has really neat ideas too . It's amazing how she manages to kinda fill her characters personalities so flawlessly and RP as if they were seperate people. Well I guess, thats what RPing is about but I know most of my char's are always grumpy, xD Her posts are detailed but aren't to long or complicated. She really know how to keep this section running too

Next Kuro. An amazing RPer. I've known him for a while and he's been here for a long time. You can really see how his RPing prowess as grown. He has memorable characters that always seem to have an impact in the RP and on the characters. He can convey any emotion he wants through the use of words and his post. Interesting abilities, and backround make for great interesting char's, with unique abilities. He has great detail in his posts and a sort of fluidness to them. Everything fits together perfectly and he doesn't repeat words and makes me want to end up reading more, xD.

Both are amazing RPers. It seems impossible to choose. So here's the conclusion to my post: I will give each a half of a vote. Because, honestly there true skills in RPing seem to bloom while RPing with each other. Shigeko and Shoda's relationship seems so real and amazing. They seem to be able to finish each others sentences off and together show such a sense of love. Making both memorable characters. When training with puppets or running around INS there's always a light hearted sense about it xD Like the vibe from two great friends . It's as if there posts are apart of some great book. I picture the word like vivid manga pages in my head, x) So I can't give a single vote to either so I hope giving a half vote is allowed, xD

I can't even begin to compete with these great RPing legends . Alone they are a force to be reckoned with, xD When RPing together, they are two of the best RPers anywhere.

=)

XD you guys make me out to be good at RPing, xP

[schrodinger]

Im too tired for drawn out posts right now...the long and short is this.

This Badge Battle (from my understanding) Is for the best pinky Roleplayer...not nessasarily any other catagory. Thus i base my choice as such.

Nyanki- Is awsome. Her posts are clear and to the point, and she does an awsome job with all the technichal and orginasational things that would make my head Explode, and is an all around bad ass of the ighest order.

Ryan- Mister GangstaKage himself....yes...i dont know if this needs explanation. He is awsome, has a lot of humor, and somehow, always manages to make even the most mundane RP situations enjoyable, he brings a huge amount to the interactions of those throughout the rp section.

Kuro- The most active Rp'er pinky, who always has something interesting to bring to the table. His charachter desighns are awsome, his in depth, yet straightforeward posting style is awsome, and he doesnt make you wait around for him to post . He also happens to be funny as hell and be good at reasoning....yes another pluss. lol.

Overall: Long story short, ever pinky has their streangths and weaknesses, but this battle is about the best Rp'er, and for that, im going to have to vote for kuro.

[Nyanki]

Ooo, time to make myself vote.

It is a tough choice, but I will run through all the things I think about when I think of an RPer.

Character templates -- These two are very good at deciding what they want from their characters from the get-go, which I know is an area I struggle in, and we always admire those who can do things we ourselves can't. Although they may still experiment a bit at the start, they ultimately know what they want out of their characters before they RP with them, which is why they can write such indepth histories and personalities.

Interactive RPing -- This is the non-battle RPing, where your character wanders about the world, interacting with others. Areas of personality and other character growths are shown here. These two are very good in this area. I've had Kuro make me light-headed, and I've had Ryan make me laugh like crazy for like 20 minutes (which I guess counts as light-headed after all that oxygen I lost xD). Descriptions are very good here. They stick very good to what they have in their character templates, often not changing very much when they do go back and try to fix things. And even then, it's normally just additions.

Fighting -- Again, a skill I admire that these two have because they are comfortable with unleashing their attacks and can play fairly without seeming to put too much thought into what they need to do. They can both explain themselves well here.

OOC -- I'm sure this is an area people tend to forget, as it's not part of the game, but there are so many things an RPer can do outside of playing. These two have shown their skill here. They can put together interesting RPGs of their own, which I've read probably an equal amount of, although most are buried in the past of a time where I wasn't around. But they can put together a nice RP when they want to.
Although it is a part of the job, both of them are good with helping other members out. Be it something is OPed or someone is just asking for help with something they can't figure out, these two will surely jump up to help. Because Kuro is Mr. Rapid-Poster as he is, he tends to get to these things more often than Ryan. But Ryan still gets them now and again, and he usually has some interesting idea that I know I wouldn't have ever thought of when it's his turn.

Now, I am still mulling over the differences and all that jazz. However, it is 3:30 in the morning, and I am getting blurred in the mind. So, I will leave this post with an "I can't decide at the moment," and I'll try to edit something in before the thread gets called.